- Review article
- Open Access
Traditional Sri Lankan fermented buffalo (Bubalus bubalis) milk gel (Meekiri): technology, microbiology and quality characteristics
Journal of Ethnic Foods volume 8, Article number: 27 (2021)
Meekiri (sometimes also known as Mee-Deekiri); fermented buffalo milk gel is a deep-rooted dairy product in Sri Lankan food culture and the production of Meekiri plays an integral part in the livelihood of rural farming. Meekiri consumption is widespread irrespective of geographic boundaries, across the cultural and/or ethnic communities. In Sri Lanka, buffalo milk is predominantly used in producing Meekiri, where production has been specialized in various geographic areas in the country, associated with major buffalo farming regions. Physicochemical and microbiological quality attributes are apparent to differ in Meekiri according to varying production regions, processing techniques and storage conditions. The mouthfeel and taste of Meekiri are widely accepted to be thicker and creamier with a pleasant note and is whiter in colour compared to fermented cow milk gel/yoghurt. Since Meekiri production is localized in Sri Lanka and available as traditional know-how at the primary production level, up-to-date comprehensive scientific literature that accounts for processing and detailed product quality characteristics is lacking. Hence, this review evaluates and outlines updated information about the Meekiri production, associated buffalo farming systems, quality characteristics of Meekiri including physicochemical, sensorial and microbiological aspects in the final product.
Buffalo farming in Sri Lanka is one of the vital livestock sectors, which is well integrated into the traditional livelihoods of rural dairy farmers. Bubalus bubalis, or commonly known as water buffalo, has been classified into two groups mainly the Swamp buffaloes of Southeast Asia and River buffaloes predominantly found in the Indian subcontinent . The mainstream of buffalo milk produced in Sri Lanka is destined to produce fermented water buffalo’s milk gel, which is commonly known as Meekiri or Curd, throughout the country. Meekiri is a unique fermented dairy product and ubiquitous processed buffalo milk-derived dairy food in Sri Lankan food culture. Fermentation of milk is one of the major preservation techniques to preserve the excess milk yield . The origin of fermented milk is dated back to ancient civilizations and evolved with culinary skills along with the advances in keeping livestock and agricultural practices . Meekiri has been an integral part of food since ancient times, where it has been used in royal cuisines too. According to famous folk tales (unwritten literature illustrating historical values of various aspects) on “Andare” (the legendary royal comedian in Sri Lanka), Meekiri has been considered as one of the best appealing and overwhelming desserts with a greater tempting. The concept associated with this folk tale is adopted as a general belief and is still applicable among consumers, where even if the person is satisfied with food, Meekiri is irresistible as a dessert.
Traditional fermented foods are playing a vital role in socio-economic and cultural development in local communities. Sri Lanka has long been renowned for its traditional foods and the “Pasgorasa” (five tastes of milk) was made of excess fresh milk included a combination of five items; (1) “Ksheer” (Sanskrit word for milk), (2) “Deekiri” (fermented cow milk), (3) “Githel” or “Dunthel” (Ghee, Githel made from cow milk & Dunthel made from buffalo milk), (4) “Wendaru or Yodaya” (cream), (5) “Moru or Mohuru” (whey). Moreover, there has been a traditional sweet Buddhist offering called “Chatu Madura’’ (the four delicacies) and it is an amalgamation of (1) ghee, (2) “Wendaru”, (3) concentrated and solidified sugar cane syrup “Jaggery or Hakuru” [however, at present any type of jaggery is commonly used, which is often obtained by concentrated thick brown solid from coconut (Cocos nucifera) or kithul palm (Caryota urens) flower sap] and (4) bee honey  (Prof. Nimal Perera and Ven Nakulugamuwe Nimala thero, personal communications, 15 August 2021). Curd makes an unbeatable combination with kithul treacle. Kithul treacle is made from the sap collected from the inflorescence of the kithul palm, which is native to Sri Lanka. The sap is boiled down to dark brown syrup, thick and sweet in flavour, with resembling dates and a slight hint of caramel. This combination is often offered at Buddhist alms-giving ceremonies as a tradition, illustrating the importance of Meekiri in Sri Lankan food culture. Health benefits of such traditional foods can be passed into modern diets with proper interventions of modern food processing technologies , since food and health are directly related as detailed in Ayurvedic traditional methods of food habits and dietary preparations . Fermented buffalo milk has been used as numerous indigenous beverages in Asia, e.g. Dahi, Mohi, Dadih [7,8,9] and in Sri Lanka, Meekiri has been dominated in the food culture . Meekiri has been a traditional ethnic food for many years in Sri Lanka, although numerous competitive foods, e.g. Greek-style yoghurt, are emerging in the Sri Lankan market. Meekiri still holds its position as a dessert in Sri Lankan food culture, among the other popular dairy desserts, e.g. ice cream, across varying generations without a competition.
Meekiri is obtained by fermentation of buffalo milk using mesophilic bacterial cultures at room temperature, as an attempt to preserve the milk until consumption as well as a strategy for value-addition . Sri Lankans are widely appreciating its thick consistency and characteristic taste as a local delicacy. In Sri Lankan food culture, consumption of Meekiri is dated back from ancient times and have been enjoying it as a dessert, breakfast as well as a snack . Meekiri is associated with the cultural values of regional communities, where gifting a freshly made Meekiri in a clay pot wrapped in a woven coconut palm basket (Fig. 1A) is a common tradition in the southern part of Sri Lanka, which is believed to be the origin of Meekiri. Local production of Meekiri is a communal affair, where the members of the whole family participate in preparation, especially in heating the milk in a big vessel without letting it get the burnt taste. Traditional know-how passed through the generations and local specialities in the production of Meekiri are available in regions where Meekiri is predominantly produced in Sri Lanka. As a consequence of homemade bulk starter cultures or usage of previous day curd (e.g. back-slopping), an enormous variety of starter culture bacteria (e.g. lactic acid bacteria) consortium has resulted in products from different regional origins [10, 13]. Consequently, a wide array of product physicochemical properties has resulted. Investigating the hundred years old recipes in producing Meekiri and combining them with in-depth current knowledge is an essential key strategy in preserving the value of traditional ethnic buffalo milk-derived dairy products in Sri Lanka. Thus, detailed aspects of buffalo milk, the processing technology into Meekiri and its product quality characterization attributes are accounted for in this review.
Buffalo milk is unique compared to cow milk and contains a higher level of fat (6.7% vs. 3.7%), total protein (4.70% vs. 3.50%) and calcium (205 vs. 115, mg 100 mL−1) content than that of cow milk, respectively . Compared to cow milk, buffalo milk also has higher casein to protein ratio, a factor that is usually appreciated in producing stronger/firmer milk gels. Due to less water content (83.2% vs. 87.2%, respectively) and higher total solids (16.3% vs. 12.8%, respectively) than cow milk, buffalo milk is perceived to be thicker . Visually, buffalo milk is relatively whiter than cow milk, due to a shortage in β-carotene , the pigment responsible for yellowness. As a consequence, Meekiri is also whiter in tone compared to fermented cow milk gel/cow milk curd, which is also referred to as “Deekiri” (Fig. 2). Buffalo milk contains higher peroxidase activity, and therefore, it has comparatively better natural preservative ability compared to cow milk . The superior richness of constituents compared to cow milk makes buffalo milk a highly suitable and greatly demanded dairy product in Sri Lanka. Casein micelles, the primary structure of casein proteins and minerals in buffalo’s milk, is highly mineralized and this resulted in higher mineral (calcium and phosphate) content in buffalo milk. Because of the higher mineral, fat and protein content in buffalo milk, its coagulation properties and milk gel characteristics are often superior compared to usual cow milk fermented gels .
Current status of the buffalo industry in Sri Lanka
Buffalo farming in Sri Lanka plays an important role in livestock production, and therefore, buffaloes are important contributors to the national dairy value chain/supply. The agriculture sector contributes about 7% of the national GDP of Sri Lanka , whereas the contribution of the livestock sector to the national GDP is around 0.8% . Buffalo-keeping has been an integral part of the farming systems of Sri Lanka from an ancient time where the buffalo has been reared for multiple purposes including milk for producing Meekiri, manure and draft mainly for paddy cultivation [19, 20]. The current buffalo population in Sri Lanka is estimated at 0.47 million heads . It is largely concentrated in the eastern (28%), southern (16%) and north-central (16%) provinces located in the dry and intermediate zones which collectively account for approximately 60% of the total buffalo population in the country . A considerable proportion of buffalo farming in Sri Lanka is family level, and therefore, the production statistics are not well reflected, as those households often produce buffalo milk with the intention for consumption . The variation in the buffalo population, milk production (buffalo and cow) in Sri Lanka over the last 10 years is shown in Fig. 3.
In 2019, the total annual milk production in Sri Lanka was just above 424 million litres and approximately 16% of this (67.5 million L) comprised of buffalo milk . The highest buffalo milk production was coming from the eastern province (21 million L) followed by north-western (15.7 million L), north-central (13.2 million L) and southern (12.2 million L) provinces (Table 1). In Sri Lanka, the majority of the buffalo farmers rear buffaloes for draft power or as a source of ready cash, and therefore, a fewer number of buffaloes are kept for milking purposes . Based on the statistics, it can be estimated that only 24% of the total buffalo population is being milked currently, suggesting that there is a huge potential exist for further expansion of the industry in terms of milk production although the majority of buffalo milk comes from smallholder herds .
Indigenous/local, Murrah, Nili-Ravi, Surti and their crosses are the predominant buffalo breeds found in Sri Lanka [19, 25]. The majority of the farmers rear local buffaloes with Murrah/Nili-Ravi crosses . The proportion of local, pure-bred and cross-bred buffaloes were estimated at 69%, 6% and 25%, respectively . Statistics suggest that there is a huge variation in average milk production per buffalo per annum (Table 1) depending on the type of animals kept, agro-ecology and systems of rearing. The highest productivity is observed in Kurunegala District (2103 L/buffalo/year), and the lowest was observed among Mannar, Rathnapura, Badulla and Kandy Districts (< 200 L of milk per buffalo per annum). It has been reported that the average production of milk from Murrah, Nili-Ravi and Surti breeds is about 1400–2000 kg, 1500–2000 kg and 1500–1800 kg, respectively, with 7–8% fat in lactation of 305 days [1, 25].
Buffalo production systems in Sri Lanka
Buffalo production systems in Sri Lanka can be classified according to the breed and husbandry practices, which are closely related to the agro-ecology and climatic factors . Buffalo farm management and uses vary with the agro-ecology, rainfall and cropping patterns. In all these systems, productivity and reproductive performance are at sub-optimal levels [20, 26]. Major buffalo production systems in Sri Lanka and their characteristics are summarized in Table 2.
The utilization of buffaloes for milking has not been uniform within Sri Lanka. In some districts, e.g., Hambantota, Batticaloa, Polonnaruwa and Trincomalee, buffaloes were mainly reared as dairy animals, since long time ago. Nevertheless, at present, the same regions are still renowned for traditional Meekiri production. For example, “Tissa Meekiri” which is historically being prepared in the Tissamaharama area of the southern province of the country is recognized as excellent quality and ideal Meekiri by general consumers, owing to traditional know-how and quality of the forages available in the area . Free-grazing extensive system and semi-intensive systems of management are the most widely spread management systems in Sri Lanka in relation to buffalo farming. A semi-extensive buffalo farm and milking are illustrated in Fig. 4. Zero-supplementary feeding, absence of housing and free grazing are the main characteristics of extensive management systems [19, 26].
It has been reported that just over one-tenth of the country’s buffalo population was utilized for milking . Buffalo milk was thus mainly utilized for preparing Meekiri and Dunthel (ghee) and to a lesser extent for domestic consumption as fluid milk . Traditional milking practices of buffaloes slightly differ from the modern milking practices in rural communities. In the past, the calves were separated from the milking buffaloes during the night and on the following day morning (preferably before 5.50 a.m.) they were milked. Short before starting to milk, the separated calf is allowed to suckle for a while to stimulate milk letdown process to facilitate easy and smooth milking. Thereafter, the calf was allowed to suckle freely throughout the day until it is separated during the night [27, 29].
Major Meekiri producing regions
In Sri Lanka, Meekiri production is largely associated with buffalo farming areas due to the “locally produced” concept or small-scale production at the household level, with no excess milk yield to sell or transport to another processing plant. Meekiri is a value-added product from buffalo milk, and therefore, farmers earn considerably higher profit by selling Meekiri instead of raw buffalo milk to another intermediate buyer or milk collector. At present, almost all buffalo farmers are producing Meekiri either at the household level or local community level or localized farm level, without being transported into a central processing plant. In Sri Lanka, however, specifically, there is no island-wide or large-scale buffalo milk collecting cold chain. This is mainly due to several reasons, i.e. (1) insufficient milk production for meeting the demand of large-scale and centralized Meekiri production; (2) not having excess raw milk yield to sell; (3) greater profit margin of selling Meekiri than raw milk to primary producers and (4) economic benefits of distributing/transporting final product instead of raw milk. However, from various geographic areas in Sri Lanka, few specific cases report the opposite. For example, about 92% of the buffalo farmers in the Thanamalwila area (Monaragala district) used to earn money by only selling raw buffalo milk and only 8% of the farmers are involved in the production of Meekiri . In the peri-urban dairy production system in the Seethawakapura area (Western province), 13% of the farmers are involved in producing Meekiri . In the coconut triangle (the area between Puttalam, Kurunegala and Colombo), buffalo milk is predominantly converted into Meekiri, since the local demand is high . Because of all those reasons, major Meekiri production regions and buffalo farming areas are confounded. Some of the Meekiri production areas are well known and popular among consumers. Figure 5 shows such popular and major Meekiri production regions in Sri Lanka.
Production of Meekiri
Fresh buffalo milk is converted into Meekiri, through a microbial fermentation process, where fermentation is practised as a mode of preservation and extending the shelf-life of excess milk yield . Even though various fermented buffalo milk products are available in the world, Meekiri is the sole and popular and commercially available fermented buffalo milk-derived product in Sri Lanka. Production of Meekiri involves several steps as shown in schematic illustration (Fig. 6). Meekiri production is an ancient art practised in Sri Lanka as a cottage industry for a long time. The majority of producers are manufacturing Meekiri using the milk obtained from their own herds. First, milk is boiled over an open fire (firewood was used for heat generation upon burning) for 20–30 min within 3 h from milking and then cooled to around 35–40 ºC. The majority of the curd makers used aluminium vessels for milk collection and boiling. In the production process of Meekiri, the milk lactose is converted into lactic acid by the action of added starter culture’s activity . Starter cultures are added as freeze-dried pellets or commonly as a portion of mother culture maintaining at household-level or back-sloping inoculation from the previous day’s production (referred to as Muhun in Sinhalese). This lactic acid production will reduce the milk pH, and at the isoelectric point of casein (pH 4.6), milk coagulation occurs . At cottage level production of Meekiri, Muhun is added before the boiled milk is completely cooled to room temperature. These Muhun were obtained from previously prepared Meekiri (approximately 1 day old) based on producers evaluation of the best Meekiri quality. Therefore, continuously, Muhun is changing in accordance with the manufacturer’s selection and maintenance. The temperature of the milk at the time when Muhun is added could be determined by experience. After inoculating with Muhun, the mixture is stirred firmly to distribute it evenly in the milk base. Usually, a spoon made of cleaned and polished coconut shells with a long wooden handle has been used. Then, the mix is poured into pre-washed and dried clay pots of equal size, which are left open and allowed to coagulate at room temperature (~30–35 °C). The minimum time required to achieve satisfactory curdling is 3–5 h from the inoculation which can be extended up to 36 h or even 72 h in some cases. It is finally sealed by wrapping a piece of oil paper or natural banana leaf over the pot. The liquid that separates after the curd has formed is called whey or buttermilk (referred to as Moru or Mohuru in Sinhalese) and is considered a healthy drink that is consumed in the morning by certain villagers. Because of different processing parameters and conditions adopted at household production of Meekiri, coupled with undefined starter cultures and traditional practices, properties and quality of Meekiri are widely varied.
Storage, packaging and marketing
Traditionally, coagulation of buffalo milk is achieved in a clay pot and subsequently possible to store in a range of temperatures, mainly 4 °C (7 days of shelf-life) or ambient room temperature (1–3 days of shelf-life) until consumption . At present, in Sri Lanka, the most popular packaging material for Meekiri is clay pots covered with paper or polythene cover. The use of low-density polyethylene (LDPE) cups and jars, however, is emerging as packaging material among some large-scale producers. Yet, the Meekiri packed in clay pots is highly preferred by the consumer, since Meekiri in plastic cups has impaired sensory properties, especially in terms of flavour and texture. Excess whey is absorbed by the clay pots and help to maintain product textural properties. Figure 7 illustrates the two common styles of storing and marketing of Meekiri in Sri Lanka. Clay pots, earthenware, contain a relatively high amount of iron oxide, as a result of firing them under direct heat and thus develop the characteristic brick-red colour, depending on the type of clay used as a raw material . Firing contributes to food safety aspects of earthenware as well. Such clay pot is chemically inactive and does not react with the Meekiri. It is permeable to moisture and gasses, and therefore, shelf-life is limited. Compared to plastic containers, clay pots are heavy and easily broken, which is not widely appreciated along the distribution and supply chain. In contrast, the plastic packaging of Meekiri provides numerous benefits over the clay pots, such as its flexibility in moulding, easiness to print packaging and marketing information, lightweight, easiness in transportation, great durability, resistance to food chemicals and maintaining product consistency.
Physicochemical characteristics of Meekiri
The mean composition of Meekiri is varying, but it usually contains ⁓ 88% of water, 7–8% of fat, ⁓ 3.4% protein, ⁓ 5.2% lactose, ⁓ 0.14% calcium and ⁓ 0.09% phosphorus . The physicochemical characteristics of organoleptically optimal Meekiri have a firm texture, pleasant aroma and glossy surface compared to the counter product (i.e. Deekiri; fermented cow’s milk gel). Meekiri is creamy with a thick mouth-feel and higher viscosity and gives a sour taste. Also, Meekiri must be free from extraneous materials and free from dirt that could origin due to unhygienic practices at small scale non-standardized household production. The fermented gel (body of the Meekiri) must not be in a gritty texture and should be able to obtain a clean cut with a spoon without cracks in the body. The texture of the body must be consistent without visible air pockets (Fig. 8A). Whey separation onto the surface, also known as syneresis, should not occur from the gel and may have a thin fat layer on top of the curd body. This is associated with the absence of a key processing step (e.g. homogenization) at small-scale rural production. Comparing the syneresis values between Meekiri and Deekiri has reported that Meekiri results in lower syneresis than Deekiri . The pH of the optimal Meekiri must be 4.5–4.6. No major preservatives are recommended, where some producers add ascorbic acid up to 1 g/kg. The manufacture of Meekiri does not require any stabilizers, since buffalo milk contains a higher amount of fat, total solids compared to cow milk, where often a stabilizer is added when fermented gels are produced. Consumption of Meekiri is still mainly practised as a dessert  either with palm treacle: kithul (Caryota urens) or coconut (Cocos nucifera) syrup or table sugar (Fig. 8B), where many other culinary potentials are also available. The comparable product for Meekiri is Dahi in India. In the western world, a similar product for Meekiri is Greek-style yoghurt, a concentrated cow milk yoghurt, which has a similar mouthfeel and texture.
Microbiology of Meekiri
Production of Meekiri involves the use of starter culture bacteria, either sourced commercially or maintaining at the household level. Thus, a wide array of bacterial strains may occur and gives rise to various unidentified and unclassified properties [10, 34]. Meekiri contains lactic acid bacteria belonging to several genera. These bacteria can be incorporated into Meekiri either as starter cultures, can naturally stem from raw milk or introduced into milk during various steps in milk handling . Traditionally, Meekiri from the previous fermentation is used as the inoculum to introduce starter cultures, i.e. back-slopping. Thus, microbial communities in Meekiri may highly vary among various production sites. From a recent study, we showed five different groups of LAB diversity at the species level from Meekiri samples collected from 22 local production sites across Sri Lanka . Among those LAB isolated from Meekiri samples, we mainly identified Limosilactobacillus fermentum, Latilactobacillus curvatus, Lactobacillus acidophilus and Lactiplantibacillus plantarum with promising probiotic potentials. It has been found that Meekiri contains a combination of various lactic acid bacteria (i.e. Lactobacillus delbrueckii subsp. lactis, L. planatarum, L. helviticus, L. delbrueckii subsp. bulgaricus and L. casei subsp casei, Streptococcus thermophiles and S. lactis) in addition to Saccharomyces cerevisiae, Micrococcus spp., and Bacillus spp . Kanthale is one of the popular regions in Sri Lanka for Meekiri production, and from this region, thirty-six Lactobacillus strains have been identified from spontaneously fermented traditional Meekiri in clay pots . The microbiological composition of starter cultures used for the production of fermented buffalo milk has been investigated and identified as Lactococcus lactis ssp. lactis, Lactococcus lactis ssp. cremoris, Streptococcus thermophilus, Lactobacillus delbrueckii ssp. bulgaricus, Lactobacillus acidophilus and Lactobacillus helveticus . Predominantly, the lactic acid bacteria available in raw milk contribute to the diversity of bacterial consortium in Meekiri. Lactobacillus acidophilus and Lactobacillus delbrueckii ssp. bulgaricus have been identified as the dominating species in raw buffalo milk, while Steptococcus thermophilus, Lactococcus lactis ssp. lactis and Lactobacillus delbrueckii ssp. bulgaricus were identified as the most abundant species in raw cow’s milk . The bacterial composition of buffalo milk and thus the Meekiri may be subject to vary with geographical areas and climatic conditions. Although to date, there is no published information available regarding the geographical variation of microbiota in Meekiri, as a consequence of variation associated with raw buffalo milk in Sri Lanka. From fermented buffalo milk in Pakistan, Lactobacillus delbrueckii subsp. bulgaricus and Streptococcus thermophilus have been identified as predominant lactic acid bacteria. Also, some contaminants, e.g. Staphylococcus, Micrococcus and Saccharomyces spp. were observed in fermented buffalo milk samples . The raw milk microflora will further depend on buffalo’s health status (e.g. mastitis conditions), diet and feeding practices, milking procedures, milk handling utensils, sanitation practices, and house flora. In raw buffalo milk, Lactococcus and Streptococcus dominated in the first 24 h and after storing it for 72 h, Pseudomonas and Acinetobacter genera have also been observed . Therefore, the authors suggest that buffalo raw milk should immediately be chilled or processed to extend the shelf-life and must be monitored for the presence of Paenibacillus.
Evaluation of probiotic attributes of Lactobacillus spp. isolated from fermented milk from cow (Deekiri) and buffalo milk (Meekiri) samples collected from the Kandy district reported that they could grow at low pH (i.e. pH 3) and able to survive at 0.3% bile salt while showing antimicrobial activity against E.coli and Pseudomonas aeruginosa . A research study investigating the shelf available Meekiri in Sri Lanka reported that the microbial count of L. acidophilus was higher than the minimum required level (107 CFU/g) up to 12 days of shelf-life and survived in low pH (1.5–4.24) with tolerance to bile salt . This indicates that naturally occurring Meekiri tends to contain probiotic bacteria. According to FAO/WHO , probiotics are “live microorganisms which when administered in adequate amounts confer health benefits on the host”. Probiotic bacteria contained in the buffalo milk most likely die during the heat treatment and probable probiotic bacteria might end in Meekiri though inoculum or house flora and might exert a probiotic effect on the host. Another study revealed that incorporation of Bifidobacterium longum into Meekri is possible and bifidobacteria showed a satisfactory survival of 106 CFU/g up to 3 days of storage in clay pots at 29 °C, while after 4 days of storage bifidobacteria counts were not acceptable . However, the inclusion of probiotic bifidobacteria into Meekiri did not alter the organoleptic properties while improving consumer acceptability. Meekiri should be free from surface-grown mould and other external contaminants.
Consumer acceptance and satisfaction with Meekiri depends on its organoleptic quality attributes, and therefore, optimizing those properties is crucial to sustaining the Meekiri production in the market. Several quality defects, however, are visible in Meekiri as shown in Fig. 9. Such quality defects can be mainly divided into two major domains, e.g. texture-related and flavour-related defects. Meekiri is expected to have a strong solid-like gel and often gel structure losing, cracks, syneresis are some of the common textural quality defects while sourness, too-oily mouthfeel, bitterness and taste associated with packaging are major flavour-related defects.
Product standards and adulterations
Sri Lanka Standards Institute (SLSI)  describes the Meekiri should have a minimum of 8.5% milk solids non-fat, 4.5 of maximum pH level and absence of E. coli. Buffalo milk, however, is often adulterated with cow milk, because cow milk is relatively high in availability on a year-round basis and lower farm gate price compared to buffalo milk . This creates an ethical and legal requirement in detecting cow milk in buffalo milk or Meekiri. In Sri Lanka, two-thirds of the common market available Meekiri brands are adulterated with cow milk . This mixing of both types of milk has an impact on the fat content, where it could lower the recommended level standards set by SLSI , of which the minimum level of fat percentage in Meekiri should not be lower than 7.5%. Apart from the compositional and organoleptic quality changes in Meekiri, the non-declared incorporation of cow milk into Meekiri will raise food safety concerns among the consumers with allergies or intolerance to cow milk .
Buffalo milk is rich in trace elements (e.g. iron, copper, zinc, manganese, selenium, iodine, chromium, molybdenum, cobalt, fluorine, nickel, silicon, arsenic and boron) and concentrations are varied with the stage of lactation, nutritional status and health condition of udder and animal, genetic factors, feeding and environmental factors. These elements can be accumulated in forage plants as a result of those been up taken from soil and water. When buffaloes graze on such sources, trace elements are transferred and reach the blood and then milk. A recent study conducted by the University of Peradeniya, Sri Lanka , found a variation in minerals among the buffalo milk samples (n = 78) sourced from twelve locations in Sri Lanka. They reported buffalo milk collected from the Embilipitya area to contain a higher amount of Arsenic (As) and Lead (Pb), while samples collected from Weeravila and Ambalantota contained a lower amount of As and Pb, respectively. Higher calcium and potassium levels were reported from milk obtained from the Polonnaruwa area. Alarmingly, higher concentrations of As and Pb were found in Meekiri sourced from those areas. This is probably since Meekiri is mainly produced in clay pots, where the risk for contaminating the fermented milk with heavy metals is high from the clay. This is because clay absorbs toxic metal from its environment, holds inside the porous structure and mitigates into the Meekiri. However, results must be interpreted cautiously since the number of samples (n = 4) analysed is very limited, raising concerns about reproducibility and representability. Yet, the study cast some light on these aspects, where no published data are available in this regard.
In traditional Meekiri production, the milk base is first sieved to remove unwanted and extraneous materials present in the milk. Subsequent boiling (20–30 min) of milk or industrial pasteurization (72 °C, 15 s) destroys almost pathogenic microbes, many spoilage type microbes and enzymes that are deteriorating the milk proteins and fats. Fermenting buffalo milk into Meekiri has been suggested as an effective strategy to eliminate Listeria monocytogenes, where the growth of Listeria was not observed below the pH level of 5.5 . This inactivation of Listeria is mainly due to low pH, increasing acidity and production of bacteriocins such as nisin. Lactobacillus strains found in Meekiri samples in Kanthale district, Sri Lanka, reported exhibiting strain-specific antimicrobial properties against several pathogenic bacteria, while demonstrating the highest antibacterial activity against Listeria monocytogenus . Therefore, it can be argued that the natural microflora used in traditional Meekiri production in the Kanthale area in Sri Lanka have antibacterial activity, which could protect the curd from bacterial spoilage to enhance the shelf-life while enhancing food safety from food-borne bacterial diseases.
Nutrition and health benefits
Consumption of buffalo milk feels more satiety as compared to drinking the same amount of cow milk and thus provides numerous health benefits such as controlling the food intake. Therefore, it provides benefits for healthy bones and dental health. Buffalo milk is a good source of protein, for those who seek for high protein drinks to boost muscle mass compared to cow milk. Though buffalo milk is rich in fat, the level of cholesterol is lower and thus pauses comparatively less health risk compared to cow milk. Moreover, Meekiri contains a higher amount of vitamin A, which is important for normal vision. Buffalo milk contains a higher amount of minerals such as calcium and phosphate, while lower sodium content is compared to cow milk  and thus being a rich source of bioavailable essential minerals for consumption.
Consumption of Meekiri promotes health and the use of Meekiri in traditional medicines dated back to ancient periods in Sri Lankan history. Meekiri enhances lactose digestion, stimulates intestinal immunity and peristalsis . In individuals suffering from lactase deficiency, lactose intake may cause intestinal discomfort, leading to a condition known as lactose intolerance. The reduction in the lactose concentration, as a consequence of fermentation, and the occurrence of a large number of viable bacteria containing β-galactosidase have allowed lactose intolerant individuals to consume fermented dairy products  such as Meekiri. Consumption of Meekiri can be used as a prevention and/or treatment for diarrhoea due to rotavirus infection and prolonged antibiotic use. Further, Meekiri has been considered favourable to overcome health conditions such as gastritis and constipation especially during critical periods of life such as pregnancy, lactation and times of ill health [54, 55]. Curd serves as a suitable delivery vehicle for probiotic bacteria which provide several health benefits through improved gut microbiota composition . Moreover, since fermented milk products like curd were reported to prevent some cancers, reduce serum cholesterol and reduce hypertension , Meekiri may be used to treat such conditions.
Perception survey about Meekiri
To evaluate the general consumer perception about the Meekiri, we conducted an online survey using Mentimeter (Stockholm, Sweden). The survey was distributed among general consumers and a total of 123 responses were obtained. Respondents were asked to indicate their first impression of Meekiri in one word. Each responded had one opportunity to indicate their opinion and all responses were summarized in the word cloud in Fig. 10. The majority responded to Meekiri as “delicious”.
Cost of production and economics of buffalo production
Buffalo plays a pivotal role in overall social development through supplying milk, meat, hides and draft power for agricultural operations . Buffalo farming significantly contributes to the sustainability of mixed crop-livestock farming systems as well as to the farmers’ income and food security in Sri Lanka . According to the prevailing social, cultural and economic understandings among rural farmers, the dairy herd is considered as an easily convertible currency and a reliable living bank that not only provide daily subsistence but also the capital and ready cash at times of dire family needs to overcome the financial issues in the event of urgency [19, 20, 58]. Buffaloes are more efficient milk producers than indigenous cows ; out of two types of buffaloes (e.g. river-type and swamp-type), the river type has high lactation yields than swamp type and is thus suitable for milk production. Breeds like Murrah, Nili-Ravi, Mehsana, Jaffarabadi and Surti are examples of river-type buffalo breeds. Milk production costs are highly variable depending on the agro-ecological zone and the production system . Revenues from milk include sales of milk and the value of milk consumed by the household , whereas the costs include concentrate feeds, housing, equipment, labour, medicine, services, insurance, fuel and transport, and animals.
The cost of production (CoP) of one litre of buffalo is varied depending on the locality and the production system. On average, the CoP of buffalo milk ranged from 40 to 55 Sri Lankan Rupees (LKR). The share of different cost components is varied depending on the system of production (Table 3). Cost for concentrates can be identified as the major cost component that varies from 41 to 47% (Table 3). The dairy industry in the peri-urban areas of Sri Lanka is a profitable industry with the opportunity cost of family labour. If the family labour is included as an opportunity cost, the farmer can produce a litre of milk for 43 LKR. If not included, a litre of milk can be produced for 28 LKR .
Future of Meekiri
Meekiri, being well-appreciated ethnic food in Sri Lankan food culture, will continue to be an integral food item across the ethnic and sociocultural groups. With the growing population, the demand for Meekiri is expanding. To cater for the growing market, modern dairy farming and dairy processing plants are emerging in Sri Lanka with the continuous adaptation of new technologies in the processing of Meekiri. Commercial and large-scale production of Meekiri is becoming more prominent than cottage-level production, alarming the need for proper regulations in quality standards. The growing production capacities create the niche for adopting competitive, economically viable and sustainable strategies for long-term storage, preservation and marketing of Meekiri than ever before. To adopt the increased demand for buffalo milk for catering to the growing production of Meekiri, farmers tend to use improved buffalo breeds, artificial insemination programmes, improved feeding, intensive farming practices, improved housing conditions and overall management of dairy buffaloes.
Despite various barriers to consuming fresh milk due to allergies to bovine milk and lactose intolerance, fermented milk gels such as Meekiri could partly or completely overcome such limitations. Moreover, Meekiri is a rich source of calcium and it could fulfil the daily dietary requirement of calcium, which is ~ 1000 mg/day for pregnant women. In addition to fulfilling the nutritional needs, consumption of Meekiri can exert positive effects on the gut microbiota hence could be associated with overcoming or reducing the risk of various gastrointestinal disorders. Therefore, characterization and identification of microflora in traditional starter cultures in Meekiri and assessment of essential probiotic attributes and finally their applications in the preparation of probiotic incorporated functional fermented dairy products would be of utmost importance. Additionally, in vivo evaluation of desirable attributes of starter cultures originated from Meekiri for maintenance of normal microflora of the intestine and their antimicrobial properties which could be exerted due to competitive exclusion abilities or production of antimicrobial substances on pathogenic microbes must be thoroughly investigated.
Although value addition to Meekiri is not common in the regular market, value addition to consumer retail clay cups can be occasionally seen at high-end markets. Since its origin, Meekiri has been remained unchanged, without being subjected to be diversification as seen in regular cow milk yoghurt. However, scientific excellence in research on buffalo milk and coagulation into milk gel (curd) has undoubtedly gained more understanding about the quality of Meekiri. Further work must focus to improve the coagulation efficiency and properties of the final gel to cater for the growing demand with improved quality. For this purpose, the standard set by Sri Lankan Standard Institutes  must be reviewed and updated based on recent research findings, with the focus on preserving the value of authentic Meekiri and preventing possible adulterations of misleading products labelling.
Fermentation of buffalo milk into milk gel (curd), also known as Meekiri, is an indispensable dairy product in Sri Lankan food culture. Meekiri provides various health benefits, mainly due to its physicochemical attributes and ability to deliver probiotic microorganisms. Packaging materials and storage of Meekiri are important considerations. Up to date, extensive knowledge concerning the processing technology of Meekiri and its chemistry is available. There are, however, various knowledge gaps existing in the arena, highlighting the need for future research. Detailed quality characterization of buffalo milk produced in Sri Lanka is required, concerning various farm management practices and production strategies adopted at varying household levels. Future research should be aimed at breeding buffaloes for improved milk quality characteristics that are suitable for Meekiri production, identify the effects of farming systems, feeding practices and management on milk quality attributes. At present, buffalo milk is mainly used for Meekiri production and product diversification as well as innovation will play a key role in sustaining the buffalo farming industry. Moreover, consumption of Meekiri should be promoted in widespread culinary uses, as a functional food with numerous health-promoting benefits.
Availability of data and materials
Perera ERK. Water buffalo production. Peradeniya: Faculty of Agriculture, University of Peradeniya; 2001.
Khedkar CD, Kalyankar SD, Deosarkar SS. Fermented foods: fermented milks. In: Caballero B, Finglas PM, Toldrá F, editors. Encyclopedia of food and health. Oxford: Academic Press; 2016. p. 661–7. https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-12-384947-2.00286-5.
Tamime A. Fermented milks: a historical food with modern applications–a review. Eur J Clin Nutr. 2002;56:S2-15. https://doi.org/10.1038/sj.ejcn.1601657.
Ginigaddara S, Kopiyawattage K, Dissanayake SP, Kodithuwakku AN. “Neveena Krushikarmanthayata Paramparika Danumen Athwelak” (Application of traditional techniques in modern farming). Anuradhapura: Faculty of Agriculture, Rajarata University of Sri Lanka; 2020.
Tadesse NS, Beyene GF, Hordofa TB, Hailu AA. Traditional foods and beverages in Eastern Tigray of Ethiopia. J Ethn Foods. 2020;7:16. https://doi.org/10.1186/s42779-020-00050-8.
Dhanya S, Ramesh NV, Mishra A. Traditional methods of food habits and dietary preparations in Ayurveda—the Indian system of medicine. J Ethn Foods. 2019;6:14. https://doi.org/10.1186/s42779-019-0016-4.
Bhattarai RR, Das SKL. Scientific study on indigenous technology of dahi making of eastern Nepal. J Food Process Technol. 2013. https://doi.org/10.4172/2157-7110.1000253.
Harmayani E, Anal AK, Wichienchot S, Bhat R, Gardjito M, Santoso U, et al. Healthy food traditions of Asia: exploratory case studies from Indonesia, Thailand, Malaysia, and Nepal. J Ethn Foods. 2019;6:1. https://doi.org/10.1186/s42779-019-0002-x.
Venema K, Surono IS. Microbiota composition of dadih—a traditional fermented buffalo milk of West Sumatra. Lett Appl Microbiol. 2019;68:234–40. https://doi.org/10.1111/lam.13107.
Abesinghe AMNL, Priyashantha H, Prasanna PHP, Kurukulasuriya MS, Ranadheera CS, Vidanarachchi JK. Inclusion of probiotics into fermented buffalo (Bubalus bubalis) milk: an overview of challenges and opportunities. Fermentation. 2020;6:121. https://doi.org/10.3390/fermentation6040121.
Terefe NS. Emerging trends and opportunities in food fermentation. Reference module in food science. Amsterdam: Elsevier; 2016. https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-08-100596-5.21087-1.
Mihiranie S, Jayasinghe JK, Jayasinghe CVL, Wanasundara JPD. Indigenous and traditional foods of Sri Lanka. J Ethn Foods. 2020;7:42. https://doi.org/10.1186/s42779-020-00075-z.
Wirawati CU, Sudarwanto MB, Lukman DW, Wientarsih I, Srihanto EA. Diversity of lactic acid bacteria in dadih produced by either back-slopping or spontaneous fermentation from two different regions of West Sumatra, Indonesia. Vet World. 2019;12:823–9. https://doi.org/10.14202/vetworld.2019.823-829.
Abd El-Salam MH, El-Shibiny S. A comprehensive review on the composition and properties of buffalo milk. Dairy Sci Technol. 2011;91:663. https://doi.org/10.1007/s13594-011-0029-2.
Kumar R, Bhatia KL. Standardization of method for lactoperoxidase assay in milk. Lait. 1999;79:269–74.
Arora S, Khetra Y. Chapter 42—buffalo milk cheese. In: McSweeney PLH, Fox PF, Cotter PD, Everett DW, editors. Cheese. 4th ed. San Diego: Academic Press; 2017. p. 1093–101. https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-12-417012-4.00042-9.
Central Bank of Sri Lanka. Economic and Social Statistics of Sri Lanka. Statistics Department, Central Bank of Sri Lanka; 2020.
Prasannath V. Trends and developments in Sri Lanka’s livestock industry. J Stud Manag Plan. 2015;01:46–55.
Premathilaka S, Seresinhe T, Gajaweera C. Socio-economic characteristics of small scale buffalo farms in Tanamalwila Area in Moneragala District of Sri Lanka. Proc Int Semin Livest Prod Vet Technol. 2017. https://doi.org/10.14334/Proc.Intsem.LPVT-2016-p.198-203.
Jayatileka TN, Weerakkody PR, Ibrahim MNM. Livestock production under coconut plantations in Sri Lanka: 1. Social, cultural and economic aspects of buffalo production. Asian Australas J Anim Sci. 1998;11:586–96.
Department of Census and Statistics. Key Statistics of Dairy Industry 2010–2020. Sri Lanka. http://www.statistics.gov.lk/. Accessed August 2021.
Department of Animal Production and Health. Livestock Statistical Bulletin. Livestock Planning and Economic Division, Department of Animal Production and Health; 2017.
Perera B, Jayasuriya MCN. The dairy industry in Sri Lanka: current status and future directions for a greater role in national development. J Natl Sci Found. 2008;36:115–26. https://doi.org/10.4038/jnsfsr.v36i0.8050.
Ibrahim MNM, Jayatileka TN. Livestock production under coconut plantations in Sri Lanka: cattle and buffalo production systems. Asian Australas J Anim Sci. 2000;13:60–7.
Hitihamu HMSJM, Lurdu MDS. Investigation of peri-urban dairy production system in Seethawaka Area. Hector Kobbekaduwa Agrarian Research and Training Institute; 2016.
Abeygunawardena HA, Rathnayaka D, Jayathilaka WMAP. Characteristics of cattle farming systems in Sri Lanka. J Natl Sci Found Sri Lanka. 1997;25:25–38. https://doi.org/10.4038/jnsfsr.v25i1.5016.
Coombe J. Kiri Kade Curd. Daily News; 2016.
Silva LNA de, Perera BM AO, Tilakaratne L, Edqvist LE. Production systems and reproductive performance of indigenous buffaloes in Sri Lanka. Rapport—Sveriges Lantbruksuniversitet, Institutionen Foer Klinisk Kemi (Sweden); 1985.
Siriweera WI. Tradition and livelihood: a study of traditional practices and technologies in agriculture, animal husbandry, irrigation and fisheries. Colombo: National Science Foundation of Sri Lanka; 2009.
Kelly P, Woonton BW, Smithers GW. Improving the sensory quality, shelf-life and functionality of milk. In: Paquin P, editor. Functional and speciality beverage technology. Sawston: Woodhead Publishing; 2009. p. 170–231. https://doi.org/10.1533/9781845695569.2.170.
da Cruz AG, de Faria AF, Van Dender AGF. Packaging system and probiotic dairy foods. Food Res Int. 2007;40:951–6. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.foodres.2007.05.003.
Conway G. Pottery reduction firing with a fuel-burning kiln. Leonardo. 1976;9:89–93. https://doi.org/10.2307/1573113.
Hallqvist J. The importance of buffalo milk in the curd manufacture of Sri Lanka. First cycle, G2E, B.Sc. thesis. SLU, Department of Molecular Sciences, 2019.
Shangpliang HNJ, Rai R, Keisam S, Jeyaram K, Tamang JP. Bacterial community in naturally fermented milk products of Arunachal Pradesh and Sikkim of India analysed by high-throughput amplicon sequencing. Sci Rep. 2018;8:1532. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-018-19524-6.
Adikari AMMU, Priyashantha H, Disanayaka JNK, Jayatileka DV, Kodithuwakku SP, Jayatilake JAMS, et al. Isolation, identification and characterization of Lactobacillus species diversity from Meekiri: traditional fermented buffalo milk gels in Sri Lanka. Heliyon 2021. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.heliyon.2021.e08136.
Dekumpitiya N, Gamlakshe D, Abeygunawardena I, Jayaratne D. Identification of the microbial consortium in Sri Lankan buffalo milk curd and their growth in the presence of prebiotics. J Food Sci Technol Nepal. 2016. https://doi.org/10.3126/jfstn.v9i0.12579.
Wickramaratne D, Gunasena D. In vitro antibacterial activity of Lactobacillus strains in spontaneously fermented curd from Kanthale, Sri Lanka 2016.
Steinkraus K. Handbook of indigenous fermented foods, revised and expanded. Boca Raton: CRC Press; 2018. https://doi.org/10.1201/9780203752821.
Aziz T, Khan H, Bakhtair S, Naurin M. Incidence and relative abundance of lactic acid bacteria in raw milk of buffalo, cow and sheep. J Anim Plant Sci. 2009;19:168–73.
Soomro AH, Masud T. Protein pattern and plasmid profile of lactic acid bacteria isolated from dahi, a traditional fermented milk product of Pakistan. Food Technol Biotechnol. 2007;45:447–53.
Li L, Renye JA, Feng L, Zeng Q, Tang Y, Huang L, et al. Characterization of the indigenous microflora in raw and pasteurized buffalo milk during storage at refrigeration temperature by high-throughput sequencing. J Dairy Sci. 2016;99:7016–24. https://doi.org/10.3168/jds.2016-11041.
Shuhadha M, Panagoda G, Madhujith T, Jayawardana I. Evaluation of probiotic attributes of Lactobacillus sp. isolated from cow and buffalo curd samples collected from Kandy. Ceylon Med J. 2017;62:159. https://doi.org/10.4038/cmj.v62i3.8519.
Rajapakse N, Jeganathan B, Wijesinghe DGNG, Chandrasekara A. Assessing the probiotic effect of buffalo milk curd. Faculty of Agriculture Undergraduate Research Symposium, Sri Lanka: Faculty of Agriculture, University of Peradeniya, Peradeniya; 2014, p 76. http://researcharchive.wintec.ac.nz/5434/1/Full_Proceedings.pdf.
FAO/WHO. Evaluation of health and nutritional properties of powder milk and live lactic acid bacteria; 2001.
Jayamanne VS, Adams MR. Survival of probiotic bifidobacteria in buffalo curd and their effect on sensory properties. Int J Food Sci Technol. 2004;39:719–25. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2621.2004.00835.x.
Sri Lanka Standard Institution (SLSI). Specification for fermented milk products-Curd; 1988.
Borková M, Snášelová J. Possibilities of different animal milk detection in milk and dairy products-a review. Czech J Food Sci. 2005;23:41–50.
Randiwela RGGVW, Mangalika ULP, Adikari AMJB, Pathirana APDG, Weeragalla WAPP. PCR based assay for the detection of cow’s milk adulteration in buffalo curd. Int J Livest Res. 2018;8:67–79. https://doi.org/10.5455/ijlr.20180424043903.
Sheehan WJ, Phipatanakul W. Tolerance to water buffalo milk in a child with cow milk allergy. Ann Allergy Asthma Immunol. 2009;102:349.
Wijesinghe K, Vidanarachchi J, Diyabalanage S, Chandrajith R. Quantification of selected essential and toxic elements in raw buffalo milk and fermented gel (meekiri) from different regions of Sri Lanka by ICP-MS; 2018.
Zachar P, Šoltés M, Kasarda R, Novotný J, Novikmecová M, Marcinčáková D. Analytical methods for the species identification of milk and milk products. Mljekarstvo. 2011;61:199–207.
Gaucheron F. Diversité des laits et des produits laitiers dans le monde. Collection Culture Des Laits Du Monde, Paris 5–6 Mai 2010; 2011. p. 174–85.
Shiby VK, Mishra HN. Fermented milks and milk products as functional foods—a review. Crit Rev Food Sci Nutr. 2013;53:482–96. https://doi.org/10.1080/10408398.2010.547398.
Milind P, Jyoti M. Curd: a sedative with a bonus bowl of useful side effects; 2014. https://doi.org/10.7897/2230-8407.050328
Wandel M, Gunawardena P, Oshaug A, Wandel N. Heaty and cooling foods in relation to food habits in a Southern Sri Lanka community. Ecol Food Nutr. 1984;14:93–104. https://doi.org/10.1080/03670244.1984.9990777.
García-Burgos M, Moreno-Fernández J, Alférez MJM, Díaz-Castro J, López-Aliaga I. New perspectives in fermented dairy products and their health relevance. J Funct Foods. 2020;72: 104059. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jff.2020.104059.
Thapa N, Tamang JP. Functionality and therapeutic values of fermented foods. Boca Raton: CRC Press; 2015. https://doi.org/10.1201/b18279-6.
Nanda AS, Nakao T. Role of buffalo in the socioeconomic development of rural Asia: current status and future prospectus. Anim Sci J. 2003;74:443–55. https://doi.org/10.1046/j.1344-3941.2003.00138.x.
Jayaweera S, Ruwandeepika D, Kendaragama K, Fernando W, Jayarathne H, Thotawaththe T. Analysis of cost of milk production in Ratnapura district. J Agric Sci. 2016;3:24. https://doi.org/10.4038/jas.v3i1.8141.
No funding is to be declared. The authors thank Rumesh Madhusha for providing images of Meekiri.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
About this article
Cite this article
Priyashantha, H., Ranadheera, C.S., Rasika, D.M.D. et al. Traditional Sri Lankan fermented buffalo (Bubalus bubalis) milk gel (Meekiri): technology, microbiology and quality characteristics. J. Ethn. Food 8, 27 (2021). https://doi.org/10.1186/s42779-021-00105-4
- Buffalo milk
- Fermented dairy products
- Mesophilic starter culture
- Buffalo farming